Fleming Trustees

OC Register columnist has no doubt the Fleming trustees knew they were violating the Brown Act

page36_blog_entry167_1
Frank Mickadeit, The Orange County Register "But there’s no doubt in my mind the board, then populated by several members with more than 15 years of experience, knew full well what it was doing. Board members attend state seminars and learn in detail about the narrow exceptions to the Brown Act. It’s drilled into them. Lack of knowledge on this broad a scale should not be an excuse."

Mickadeit is a columnist for the Orange County Register.

Fleming-era trustees can't be trusted in closed meetings, especially in judgment of children with zero tolerance policies they would never apply to themselves

page26_blog_entry93_summary_1
Tom Russell, CUSD Board of Trustees Meeting "With what we know now, it is outrageous to expect CUSD parents to entrust their children’s futures to such ethically challenged trustees. After demonstrating that you cannot be trusted, especially in secret meetings, it is audacious for you to assume you are worthy to sit in judgment of children behind closed doors, applying zero-tolerance policies that could scar them -- and have scarred some of them -- for life. If these same zero-tolerance policies had been applied to you, you would have been booted from this district long ago. Talk about hypocrisy."

Russell made these remarks during Public Comments. Russell is the spokesperson for the CUSD Recall COmmittee.

OC Register: Fleming-era trustees' open meetings law violations were serious and chronic

page26_blog_entry69_summary_1
Editorial, The Orange County Register "The Capo board wasn’t caught simply making some innocuous errors. It engaged in a long-running pattern to conceal information from the public. That board was known as a rubber-stamp for the imperious former superintendent, James Fleming, who resigned and is now under indictment on charges related to his creation of an enemies list of parents who backed a recall of his board allies."

Stiff drives effort to indemnify trustees; makes no distinction based on scope of employment or alleged criminal activity

page69_blog_entry48_1
Duane Stiff, The Orange County Register "Jim Fleming thought he was indemnified but he wasn't. That's what brought this to my attention. You're serving the public and putting your entire estate at risk."

Thanks for clearing that up for us, Duane. A lot of people have been confused about that "serving the public part" of what Fleming was doing when he got caught. Maybe you could stop thinking about protecting your own hide long enough to explain how this is good for the district and the constituents you are supposed to be "serving." Stiff is a Fleming-era CUSD trustee.

Trustee Addonizio calls Fleming trustees' failure to hold Fleming accountable, "reprehensible"

page69_blog_entry41_1
Ellen Addonizio, Trabuco Canyon News “It is reprehensible the Fleming-era Trustees failed to hold the Superintendent accountable.”

Ellen Addonizio and Anna Bryson, two of the newly-elected members of the CUSD Board of Trustees agreed to be interviewed by the press. Addonizio and Bryson both called for the remaining Fleming-era trustees to be held accountable.

RSM Councilmenber says Fleming trustees are complict in CUSD scandals and should resign

page69_blog_entry9_1
Neil Blais, Trabuco Canyn News RSM Councilman Blais stated the four remaining Fleming-era trustees “are complicit in this whole affair and they need to step down.”

In response to the indictments and continuing problems in beleaguered CUSD, local officials from across South Orange County are now speaking out and demanding change. Blais is a Councilmember of the City of Rancho Santa Margarita.

RSM Mayor Pro Tem calls for Fleming trustees to step aside for the good of the community

page69_blog_entry35_1
Gary Thompson, Trabuco Canyon News “Good public servants would recognize that when you get to the point where you no longer have the support of the people, for the good of the community and best interests of the organization you represent, it is time to step aside.”

In response to the indictments and continuing problems in beleaguered CUSD, local officials from across South Orange County are now speaking out and demanding change. Thompson is Mayor Pro Tem of the City of Rancho Santa Margarita.

Former Trustee John Casabianca changes his testimony and joins Marlene Draper in dishing out district doublespeak

John Casabianca
Seema Mehta, The Los Angeles Times "Former Trustee John Casabianca initially testified that the timing of the [contractor] settlement, which occurred as district critics were gathering recall signatures, also played a role. But after consulting his attorney, Casabianca said the board kept the settlement confidential on the advice of its lawyer, and not because of the recall attempt."

So, first, Casabianca swears the timing of the settlement was about the recall and, then, he swears it wasn't. Plausible? Hardly. But OK under the advice of CUSD's attorneys! Guess that's why we taxpayers pay those legal beagles the big bucks.

Civil charges planned against Capistrano Unified officials

page26_blog_entry44_1
Seema Mehta, The Los Angeles Times "Orange County prosecutors plan to file a civil case against Capistrano Unified School District officials alleging that trustees illegally conducted public business in secret, including approving millions of dollars in construction cost overruns at the new district headquarters, according to grand jury transcripts unsealed Friday. The looming complaint alleging that district officials violated the state's open-meetings law is the latest controversy in the beleaguered south Orange County school district, which in May saw its superintendent and another top official indicted. Susan Schroeder, a spokeswoman for the Orange County district attorney's office, confirmed that the civil case would be filed, but declined comment on details."

RSM mayor recalls surreal experience as Fleming-era trustees praised Fleming on the very day the DA raided his offices

page59_blog_entry260_1
Tony Beall, The Los Angeles Times "And what did they do when I sat down? I got called a liar 17 times by elected trustees. They stood up one by one praising him as the greatest superintendent they'd ever known. They gave him a standing ovation, and I felt like I was in 'The Twilight Zone.' "

Beall was the last public speaker to address the Board of Trustees and Fleming at Fleming's final board meeting last summer. Just hours before, district attorney's investigators raided Fleming's office and took computers and files. Beall urged the board not to let Fleming leave with a sweet retirement package. Beall asked the board to terminate Fleming and, in the short term, put him on administrative leave. Beall is the mayor of Rancho Santa Margarita and a recall leader.

Fleming wrongdoings happened under Fleming-era trustees' watch

page59_blog_entry260_1
Tony Beall, The Los Angeles Times "What we're talking about here is Fleming, and that is only the tip of the iceberg. All these issues that are now being brought to light are things we brought directly and personally to the trustees. Those trustees turned a blind eye, put their heads in the sand. And all of this happened on their watch."

Beall is the mayor of Rancho Santa Margarita and a recall leader.

Stiff rebuffs calls for his resignation, taunts reformers and reveals his arrogant, Fleming-era roots

page136_10
Duane Stiff, The Orange County Register “You know, I have a year and a half to go. If you don’t want me on here, go start another recall."

We have a better idea. Do the honorable thing - resign now and save everyone, including the children, the trouble. But given Stiff's out-of-touch track record, his repeated failure to act in the interests of constituents and his willingness to join Benecke, Draper and Darnold in cover ups, it's surprising he woke up long enough to suggest the next best thing. Stiff is one of the four Fleming-era holdover trustees.

Fleming Trustees should be ashamed, owe public an apology

Barbara Casserly, The Capistrano Dispatch “The current CUSD Trustees who allowed that environment to exist need to be voted out of elected office because they were responsible for the management of an out of control superintendent, Jim Fleming. The Trustees should be ashamed for what they allowed to occur during the Fleming administration. The public deserves an apology.”

Casserly is a Mission Viejo resident and PTA leader.

Trustees owe public an explanation for the lies they told or condoned

Barbara Casserly, The Capistrano Dispatch “Now is the time for the CUSD Trustees to explain to the public why they lied, or allowed lies to be promulgated repeatedly by Jim Fleming. Time after time, publication after publication, the public was informed that the funds for the administration building were restricted to bricks and mortar in San Juan Capistrano. Prominent members of the public continue to believe that every dime for the new administration building could only be used for an administration building in San Juan Capistrano.”

Casserly is a Mission Viejo resident and PTA leader.

It’s business as usual at CUSD, Fleming trustees appear to have learned nothing

Brad Goff, The Orange County Register “We should see fairly quickly over the next few months if the old-guard has really learned its lesson or if it intends to continue business as usual. The fact that not a single board member has taken any responsibility whatsoever for any of the mess that the district currently finds itself in indicates to me that they probably haven’t learned anything.”

Goff is the Chairman of Citizens for a Safe Rancho Santa Margarita, a local citizen action group.

Fleming trustees in denial, refuse to take responsibility for CUSD misdeeds, attack critics instead

Brad Goff, The Orange County Register “To date, no one in the administration and not a single CUSD board member has taken personal responsibility for any of the district’s past wrongdoings. To the contrary, the last two board meetings (since the election) have seen trustees go on tirades against the recall folks, the teacher’s union president and the Orange County Register writer who reported on many of the misdeeds.”

Goff is the Chairman of Citizens for a Safe Rancho Santa Margarita, a local citizen action group.

Fleming trustees have remained tight-lipped, in denial and pointing fingers at others - it's time to take responsibility

Jonathan Volzke
Jonathan Volzke, The Capistrano Dispatch "There’s been too much silence on behalf of our elected officials over the past year. And when they did speak, it was denials a single list even existed, much less two and attempts to push the responsibility of the problems onto recall supporters, the media, the whistleblower who made it public, everyone but those elected to be responsible. That raises the most important question: What will the four veteran trustees do to apologize, to rebuild that trust?"

Volzke is the publisher of the Capistrano Dispatch.

Conflicts prevent independent investigation of Fleming by Trustees

ocregister
Editorial, The Orange County Register "Clearly, these board members don’t grasp the seriousness of what happened here. Given that it’s their own political hides they are trying to save in stopping the recall, they cannot fairly be expected to look into allegations of misbehavior by their supporters in the district staff."

The Orange County Register hits the nail on the head by exposing the obvious conflict of interest that ultimately led to the less-than-independent Waldrip investigation.

Fleming trustees remain only because they weren't on the ballot

DSC04491_2
Tom Russell, The Capistrano Dispatch “The only reason those four incumbents remain on the board is because they weren’t on the ballot. If they use their four-member majority to frustrate the voters’ demand for reform, I believe the voters will remove them from office as well.”

Russell is the spokesperson for the CUSD Recall Committee. He made this statement after being asked whether the four incumbent Trustees posed an obstacle to achieving reform in the scandal-ridden school district.

Trustees admit no wrongdoing, but settle and pay Lackey's attorney fees

Jonathan Volzke_2
Jonathan Volzke, The Capistrano Dispatch “Trustees admitted no wrongdoing in the settlement, but agreed to pay $16,000 in legal fees for Dana Point resident Ron Lackey and undergo training in the Ralph M. Brown Act, the state’s public meeting law.”

Volzke is the publisher of the Capistrano Dispatch.

Lackey filed lawsuit after obtaining evidence of improper closed session

Jonathan Volzke_2
Jonathan Volzke, The Capistrano Dispatch “Lackey filed his lawsuit in Orange County Superior Court after a former district employee provided copies of agendas for Saturday meetings trustees held under the guise of evaluating the performance of then-Superintendent Fleming ...”

Volzke is the publisher of the Capistrano Dispatch.

Waldrip report cost $30,000, finds trustee and Fleming actions "imprudent" and "ill-advised"

Jonathan Volzke_2
Jonathan Volzke, The Capistrano Dispatch "Trustees received retired Judge Stuart Waldrip’s report in January but have not commented on it. They paid Waldrip $400 an hour to compile the report, for a total of about $30,000. The report called several acts by trustees or Fleming “imprudent” or “ill-advised” but decided no laws were broken."

Volzke is the publisher of the Capistrano Dispatch.

Trustees stretch to make excuses for Brown Act violations

Jonathan Volzke_2
Jonathan Volzke, The Capistrano Dispatch “While employee performance evaluations are allowed to be discussed privately, trustees relied on the reasoning that since Fleming was responsible for anything that happened in the school district, a wide range of topics could be discussed privately.”

Volzke is the publisher of the Capistrano Dispatch.

Even after alarming evidence of Fleming's wrongdoings, Benecke would use tax dollars to pay his criminal attorney's fees

Benecke-04
Trustee Sheila Benecke, The Orange County Register "Should activities resume, he'd have every right to seek reinstatement of district-paid legal counsel."

Trustee Benecke and other Fleming trustees said a defense lawyer is no longer necessary because the grand jury investigation seems to have quieted down. However, they also said they would support providing a defense lawyer for Fleming's if investigation activities resume. Benecke and her colleagues previously said that Fleming's criminal defense attorney's fees would be paid until there was evidence of Fleming's wrongdoing. Now that the Waldrip report has provided alarming evidence of such wrongdoing, Benecke and her colleagues have decided ignore the report. This decision is just a flawed as their decision to pay Fleming's criminal defense fees last summer, when they ignored legal criteria and improperly authorized payment.

No improvement at CUSD possible until those responsible are held accountable

Brad Goff, The Orange County Register "The fact that not a single board member has taken any responsibility whatsoever for any of the mess that the district currently finds itself in indicates to me that they probably haven’t learned anything. In fact, they appear to be in complete denial..."

Mr. Goff shares the belief of many of his fellow district residents that nothing is likely to change at CUSD until those responsible for the district's past wrongdoings are held accountable by their removal from elected offices or administrative positions at CUSD.