Arrogance

Disgraced Marlene Draper spouted utter contempt for the voters she represented

page36_blog_entry322_1
Marlene Draper, The Orange County Register "When one of the ABC trustees indicated that the constituents of CUSD would be unhappy with the proposed increase in compensation, trustee Marlene Draper commented, 'It's not about them,' and pushed forward the vote approving the new, more lucrative contract offer."

The OC Register published this excerpt from a report by the OC District Attorney, dated September 2, 2008. Draper's statement was quoted from a February 25th closed session board meeting to discuss a permanent employment contract for Superintendent Carter. Draper's comment was in response to reform trustees Ellen Addonizio, Anna Bryson and Larry Christensen, who argued that a proposed $58,000-a-year raise was too high in light of the district's pending fiscal crisis. Their point was that such excesses were not in the best interests of the "them" in question...the constituents of CUSD. The District Attorney took issue with Draper's insulting, wrong-headed remark, concluding the report by mocking Draper with the obvious truth: "It is all about them."

OC Register's Mickadeit reveals slimey way Fleming trustees avoided a well-deserved criminal prosecution

page36_blog_entry342_1
Frank Mickadeit, The Orange County Register "Prosecutor Bill Feccia concluded this and many other items discussed were not within the law. But because the board can hide behind an attorney – one who wasn’t even there to provide Brown Act advice in the first place – and because Fleming told the board he’d run the agenda items by a second attorney (which the other attorney doesn’t recall), the D.A. would have a hard time proving the board had both the knowledge and intent to violate the Brown Act. Therefore a civil, not criminal, complaint."

Mickadeit is a columnist for The Orange County Register.

OC Register columnist emphasizes absurdity of trustee Draper's defense to repeated Brown Act violations

page36_blog_entry167_1
Frank Mickadeit, The Orange County Register "The catch-all Brown Act exception the board used to justify all manner of secrecy was 'Evaluation of Superintendent,' which were it strictly about Fleming’s performance would be OK. However, board President Marlene Draper told the grand jury she allowed the board to discuss just about anything in private because 'all issues pertaining to the management of the district fall under his evaluation.' "
    
Mickadeit is a columnist for The Orange County Register.

Superintendent Fleming on portables

page69_blog_entry1_1
James Fleming, The Orange County Register "I like to call them army barracks."

Fleming is the Superintendent of the Capistrano Unified School District.

Grand Jury condemns CUSD's attempts to cover up express advocacy under the guise of "informational" activity

1990-1991 Orange County Grand Jury, Examination of CUSD Mello-Roos Election

“In the opinion of the Grand Jury, it would appear that the District is far from inexperienced in conducting political campaigns and, in fact, the District’s behavior in this case shows a carefully planned and often secretive effort to push the law to the limit. Moreover, the District did not willingly file its reports when notified of the obligation. It did so under protest. Finally, the fact that the District attempted to conceal its advocacy under the guise of “informational” activity, evidences a more sophisticated approach than just an innocent mistake.”

Fleming criticized as a name-dropper, bureaucrat, too self-promoting

Terry Webster, The Las Vegas Sun "The strengths and weaknesses of all of the candidates were aired during public interviews held by the School Board and the Superintendent Search Process Committee. Following his interviews, some of the criticisms made of Fleming were that he was a name-dropper and a bureaucrat. Some also said he was too self-promoting. But Fleming said he sees nothing wrong with demonstrating he can do the job."
Fleming was being interviewed as a candidate for the position of superintendent of the Clark County School District in Las Vegas Nevada. Webster is a reporter for The Las Vegas Sun.

Sheila Benecke's arrogant, caustic tongue dishonors CUSD again, demonstrating she is unworthy to serve

Benecke McCully_2
Jonathan Volzke, The Capistrano Dispatch "Board President Sheila Benecke drew more ire during the meeting when she told the packed board room 'Any jackass can knock down a barn' and used the word 'slither' when referring to speakers approaching the podium."

Benecke made these caustic remarks at the June 4, 2007 Borad meeting. Such lack of decorum proved that Benecke, the Queen of Mean, was the real jackass, and after spewing such venom from the dais, Benecke left no doubt who the real snake was. Volzke is the publisher of The Capistrano Dispath.

RSM mayor recalls surreal experience as Fleming-era trustees praised Fleming on the very day the DA raided his offices

page59_blog_entry260_1
Tony Beall, The Los Angeles Times "And what did they do when I sat down? I got called a liar 17 times by elected trustees. They stood up one by one praising him as the greatest superintendent they'd ever known. They gave him a standing ovation, and I felt like I was in 'The Twilight Zone.' "

Beall was the last public speaker to address the Board of Trustees and Fleming at Fleming's final board meeting last summer. Just hours before, district attorney's investigators raided Fleming's office and took computers and files. Beall urged the board not to let Fleming leave with a sweet retirement package. Beall asked the board to terminate Fleming and, in the short term, put him on administrative leave. Beall is the mayor of Rancho Santa Margarita and a recall leader.

Fleming dodges real issues in pathetic attempt to take the moral high ground

page26_blog_entry44_3
James Fleming, The Orange County Register “I believe they were the ethical and moral decisions to make and I could not ignore my responsibility.”

Fleming lists achievements during his tenure, such as building campuses and winning National Blue Ribbons for high-achieving schools, and says a district-commissioned [Judge Waldrip] investigation found no laws had been broken. That report criticized Fleming for actions that were “ill-advised and imprudent.” Hey, earth to Jimbo! Those decisions may have ticked people off, but those aren't the decisions you're being prosecuted for. Just think for a minute. Could it be the years of lies, deceit, retaliation, defamation and other abuses that have finally caught up with you? It was not your "responsibility" to cross every ethical and legal line possible. And as for the district-commissioned Waldrip report, it was only a matter of time before this made-to-order whitewash would be raised as a defense. Fortunately, the District Attorney looked into the same matters, and guess what? He saw at things a little differently.

Stiff rebuffs calls for his resignation, taunts reformers and reveals his arrogant, Fleming-era roots

page136_10
Duane Stiff, The Orange County Register “You know, I have a year and a half to go. If you don’t want me on here, go start another recall."

We have a better idea. Do the honorable thing - resign now and save everyone, including the children, the trouble. But given Stiff's out-of-touch track record, his repeated failure to act in the interests of constituents and his willingness to join Benecke, Draper and Darnold in cover ups, it's surprising he woke up long enough to suggest the next best thing. Stiff is one of the four Fleming-era holdover trustees.

Newcomer Smith characterizes some critics of district facilities as people who "scream and yell and throw a tantrum"

Dennis Smith 1
Dennis Smith, The Orange County Register "You can come and yell and scream or throw a tantrum, but when we think this thing through and we have this amount of money and we’ve identified the priorities, then that’s what we do. And it’s not who can scream the loudest who will get the project done. That’s not fair to anybody."

Smith is the Superintendent of the Capistrano Unified School District.

Columnist misinterprets reasons behind recent lull in activity by district critics

Keith Stroud
Keith Stroud, The Capistrano Dispatch “The problem with writing a column that pokes fun at things that are happening in Your Town is that sometimes things are just rolling along so smoothly that there’s really little to belittle. I don’t know if it’s because the Your Town Unified School District has elected new Board Members, but all the shouting and screaming by people who had had their feelings hurt by decisions made by the School Board are suddenly quiet.”

Stroud is a former high school principal and an author and a columnist for The Capistrano Dispatch.

Condescending and disrespectful, CUSD says “Trust us, we are telling the truth, this time.”

Dwaine Goodwin, The Capistrano Dispatch “To the citizens of San Juan Capistrano from the Trustees and Superintendent of C.U.S.D. “Trust us, we are telling the truth, this time.” This is almost like a Shakespearean comedy, if it was not so very serious and involves so very much money. How so few people can cause so much angst among a community is frightening. We elect these people with a knowing trust only to be deceived and lied to until such time as the truth is unavoidable. Then they tell us to “move on.” How condescending and disrespectful can they become? Really bad choices on our part.”

Goodwin is a San Juan Capistrano resident.

Fleming trustees in denial, refuse to take responsibility for CUSD misdeeds, attack critics instead

Brad Goff, The Orange County Register “To date, no one in the administration and not a single CUSD board member has taken personal responsibility for any of the district’s past wrongdoings. To the contrary, the last two board meetings (since the election) have seen trustees go on tirades against the recall folks, the teacher’s union president and the Orange County Register writer who reported on many of the misdeeds.”

Goff is the Chairman of Citizens for a Safe Rancho Santa Margarita, a local citizen action group.

Smollar "disgruntled" due to lies - Fleming, Draper and others to blame for taking focus off teaching and learning

David Smollar, The Capistrano Dispatch "Yes, Erin Kutnick, I grew most unhappy as I learned of the lies, hype and exaggeration from the top. Anyone with a moral compass would be disgusted, and there are many in the district silently relieved at the end of the Fleming regime. For the record, I resigned, and Fleming then gave me a letter offering to “be of assistance in my future endeavors.” So much for your little innuendo hinting at something else. I’m sure Fleming would love now to say he fired me, but that’s one lie, if told, that would definitely have legal consequences for him. And yes, it’s sad that the community’s focus has been taken off teaching and learning, but the blame lies squarely at the feet of Fleming, Draper and the gang with their arrogance of power."

Kutnick is a columnist for The Capistrano Dispatch. Smollar is the former Director of Communications at Capistrano Unified School District.

Critics right, district admits lies about admin building funding but says "move on" with no accountability

ocregister
Editorial, The Orange County Register "Another source of frustration for parents supporting the recall was the district’s spending of $35 million on a bluff-top administration building, even as many schools in the district were stuck with inadequate portable classrooms. That seemed to epitomize the mentality at the district under Mr. Fleming’s reign. Critics had argued that funds for the headquarters were coming from Mello-Roos fees paid in various cities, and that such money should not be used for an administration building. District officials responded that the building was paid for with redevelopment funds from San Juan Capistrano. At a meeting Nov. 28 organized by Mr. McCully to account for the district’s school construction and renovation program – itself, a good idea that promotes openness and accountability – the district admitted the critics were right. “[CUSD] officials acknowledged for the first time ... that they had misled the public about how they would pay for a new administration building, but urged the public to move on now that the correct information has been revealed,” the Register reported."

Racial gerrymandering another symptom of arrogant CUSD leadership

ocregister
Editorial, The Orange County Register "CUSD is in the midst of a heated school board race, with many allegations of mismanagement hovering over the current board. The racially gerrymandered boundaries are another symptom of an arrogant district leadership. Instead of continuing the fight, the Capo Unified board – regardless of who wins election in November – should throw out its attendance boundaries and put together new ones that treat race and ethnicity in a neutral manner, as mandated by the law."

Common thread of CUSD scandals - arrogance of power

ocregister
Editorial, The Orange County Register "Other issues have troubled us and parents over the years, including the district’s attempt to use eminent domain against a private school and its use of racial considerations in determining new districts (in apparent violation of Proposition 209). The common thread seemed to be one of arrogance of power ... It’s hard not to agree with a recall supporter who pointed to a “culture of corruption” at the district."

CUSD a poster child to warn other districts as its culture of corruption unravels

ocregister
Editorial, The Orange County Register "An investigation doesn’t mean guilt, of course, but there have been many troubling revelations about how Mr. Fleming and the board of trustees have been running the district. It’s a story of power and arrogance, and the unraveling of the administration contains warnings for other districts."

Reader disgusted with community dissention caused by, and lack of accountability at, CUSD

Dwaine Goodwin, The Capistrano Dispatch "How so few people can cause so much angst among a community is frightening. We elect these people with a knowing trust only to be deceived and lied to until such time as the truth is unavoidable. Then they tell us to 'move on.' How condescending and disrespectful can they become?"

A CUSD resident expresses disgust over the district's refusal to assign blame or demand personal accountability for admitted lies to the public about the funding sources of the new administration building.

No improvement at CUSD possible until those responsible are held accountable

Brad Goff, The Orange County Register "The fact that not a single board member has taken any responsibility whatsoever for any of the mess that the district currently finds itself in indicates to me that they probably haven’t learned anything. In fact, they appear to be in complete denial..."

Mr. Goff shares the belief of many of his fellow district residents that nothing is likely to change at CUSD until those responsible for the district's past wrongdoings are held accountable by their removal from elected offices or administrative positions at CUSD.

Doomey admits public was misled, but takes no responsibility as public is told to "move on"

Doomey
Dave Doomey, The Orange County Register "Twice, Doomey was asked Tuesday why the public was misled. 'It was misinformation that was provided. It was corrected this evening,' Doomey said. 'But why,' somebody asked. 'I can’t answer that question,' he said, and moved on, despite insults hurled from the back of the room."

Associate Superintendent Doomey was finally forced to admit that the district had lied about the funding sources for the new administration building, but he continued to stonewall parents who wanted explanations for this deceitful conduct, avoiding all blame or accountability and, in essence, expecting offended constituents, who had been deceived about the spending of tens of millions of tax dolars, to simply "trust" him and the district ... again.